Skip to Content

Best Italian Restaurant In Pigeon Forge

Sharing is caring!

Looking for delicious Italian cuisine in the Smokies? Here is a Pigeon Forge Vacation Guide on the best Italian restaurant in Pigeon Forge.

Top Pigeon Forge Italian Restaurants
Book 5 Bedroom Cabin Gatlinburg

4 Top Rated Pigeon Forge Italian Restaurants

There’s nothing more comforting than a hearty Italian meal! While Pigeon Forge is home to some amazing restaurants that serve classic southern cuisine, you’ll be happy to know that there are quite a few places where you can eat delicious Italian dishes.

From pizza and pasta to yummy calzones there is something for everyone to enjoy. Here are 4 best Italian Restaurants in Pigeon Forge, TN.


Big Daddy’s Pizzeria

3053 Parkway, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863

Craving for some yummy Italian food in the Smokies? Head straight to Big Daddy’s Pizzeria in Pigeon Forge, TN. 

Obvious of its name, the restaurant offers some of the best pizzas in town. What makes Big Daddy’s pizza awesome is that they serve Neapolitan-style pizzas with a deliciously crispy crust.

To make their pizzas, they use special homemade dough topped with their homemade sauces and fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection inside a one-of-a-kind brick oven.

Committed to serving only the freshest ingredients, you will not find any premade pizzas and freezers inside the restaurant. 

While you can enjoy the classic cheese and pepperoni pizza you can also choose among their specialty pies like the Smoky Mountain Cheesesteak, The Carnivore, Wing It, and The Big Dill among many others.

Aside from pizza, they also serve other delicious food options including wood-fired sandwiches like Big Daddy’s Submarine, Ham & Cheese, Italian Roast Pork, and more. 

While waiting for the food to arrive the kids can check out the arcade at the back of the restaurant with plenty of classic and challenging games.

Johnny Carino’s- Pigeon Forge

2425 Parkway, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863

With over 70 locations in the United States, Johnny Carino’s is a familiar face when it comes to Italian cuisine. Although this famous food chain experienced some financial setbacks over the past years, Johnny Carino’s in Pigeon Forge remained steadfast and continued serving delicious Italian food at a fair price.

Johnny Carino’s serves a variety of Italian food, from a great selection of classic Italian appetizers and pasta like classic fettuccine Alfredo, spaghetti & handmade meatballs; to sips like Margarita, Italian soda, and other nonalcoholic beverages.

If you’re feeling a bit inspired, you can even create your own pasta where you can choose your favorite pasta and one of their signature sauces.

Mellow Mushroom- Pigeon Forge

2485 Parkway, Pigeon Forge TN 37863

Mellow Mushroom is a restaurant chain with over 200 branches located throughout the United States, two of which can be found in Pigeon Forge, TN specifically at the Island of Pigeon Forge and on the Parkway. 

Mellow Mushroom has been serving the best pizzas, calzones, and other Italian-inspired dishes for over 40 years. 

Some of their house specialties that you can try out include Pretzel Bites, Kosmic Karma Pizza, The Sausage Fest Calzone, and Giant Gourmet Cookie that is one sweet treat to beat.

Whether you choose to dine on their Parkway branch or at the Island you’ll surely enjoy every bite of your meal surrounded by a fun and artsy atmosphere that is perfect for the entire family.

Geno’s Pizza

2631 Parkway Suite #3 Pigeon Forge, TN 37863

Geno’s Pizza is another restaurant in Pigeon Forge that has served a variety of food options including yummy Italian dishes since they first started in 1984.

This family-owned and operated restaurant has been a local favorite when it comes to some delicious pizza which they make using the freshest and highest quality ingredients. 

Enjoy oven-baked sandwiches and freshly made salads or try their specialty pizzas like the Geno’s special, All Meat Lovers, Vegetarian Special, and more. 

Where to Stay in Pigeon Forge

Whether you’re in Pigeon Forge for a family vacation, romantic getaway with your sweetheart or just seeking a quiet escape for the weekend, you’ll find a variety of lodging that suits every budget and need. 

Here are some of the best places to stay in Pigeon Forge:

If you want a new and luxurious way to enjoy the Smokies, there are also unique places for serious Glamping in Pigeon Forge that you should definitely check out.

The Best Italian Restaurants In Pigeon Forge

More Pigeon Forge Vacation Resources

Don’t Miss Our Smoky Mountains Web Stories

Sharing is caring!

Best Scenic Drives in the Smoky Mountains 125+ Amazing Things To Do in the Smoky Mountains! Outdoor Adventures in the Smoky Mountains