Best Coolers For The Money- Rotomolded Cooler Review & Buying Guide
BEST COOLERS FOR THE MONEY- ROTOMOLDED COOLERS BUYING GUIDE
It’s likely this page includes links for products and services we recommend and by which we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. You can read more about our participation on our disclosure page.
Without a doubt the best coolers are rotomolded coolers. Whether you are looking for camping coolers, the best small cooler, or coolers for long road trips, rotomolded coolers are perfect. In this buyer’s guide, we searched for the best rotomolded cooler for the money, to give you a comprehensive overview of the top rated coolers on the market.
5 Best Rotomolded Camping Coolers
Rotomolded Cooler Brands
American Made HIGHLY RATED BY USER Rotomolded Pelican has been using rotomolded technology since the 70's. LIFETIME WARRANTY. Certified Bear-resistant by IGBC More economical than YETI
American made rotomolded construction Single gasket for great seal High ratings for durability and ice-storage time Ranked well against Yeti, with a lower price point Certified Bear-resistant by IGBC
Known as the "yardstick by which all coolers are measured" Yeti has a reputation for durability, Rotomolded construction & long ice storage. Comes with a price. Certified Bear-resistant by IGBC
American Made, Rotomolded, manufactured by Jackson Kayak, rated well for ice retention, extra features like bottle openers, tie-downs, and bear resistant. Higher price point than Yeti and Orca Certified Bear-resistant by IGBC
Well constructed rotomolded cooler that ranks well for ice retention at a lower price point than competitors. However, consistently received low marks for weight of product despite having great handles and other features. Certified Bear-resistant by IGBC
Considered by some to be a "Yeti knockoff" RTIC is a great cooler comparable to Yeti at a lower price point. Also consisting of the rotomolded construction has shown ability to keep ice for up to seven days in some reviews.
What is a Rotomolded Cooler?
Rotomolding is a process by which a powdered polymer is poured into a hollow mold which is then heated and rotated around two axes as the polymer melts and coats the inside of the mould. Sometimes referred to as rotational molding or rotocasting, it is a manufacturing process that has been around since the Egyptian times when they used a rotational molding process to create ceramics.
In the 1940’s and 50’s it came into use in the United States for a small number of plastics manufacturers, including some doll manufacturers. However, at the time it was considered a slow process and didn’t gain much popularity until the late 70’s and early 80’s when the process became more streamlined. By 1984 rotomolding became the manufacturing process of choice for whitewater and sea kayaks. Today, rotomolding is used in everything from military and law enforcement applications to the outdoor industry to travel mugs.
Utilizing this method to make coolers ensures that every aspect of the cooler wall is even, highly durable, and extremely insulated. That is why these coolers are in many cases the last cooler you will ever need to purchase.
Like it or not there is one cooler brand that has been able to “steal the stage” you might say when it comes to name recognition and that is YETI. Sometimes in marketing, a brand that makes it to the top becomes it’s own verb. Much like the brand Xerox is now a verb used when someone makes a copy of something on a printer, YETI, has become as they put it, “the yardstick” for all other coolers.
If you want the name recognition and a good quality rotomotor cooler, you won’t go wrong with a YETI. The YETI Tundra comes in 14 different sizes so there is definitely a cooler for you if you absolutely must have a YETI. Here are some of the most popular sizes for you to check out. Keep in mind that the numbers do not always equal actual quart size with YETI. For example, while the YETI Tundra 20 is 20.8 quarts, the YETI Tundra 65 is only 57.2 quarts.
Having a really big party? Check out the YETI Tundra 350! Whoa!! This amazing rotomolded cooler is 19,000 cubic feet and holds over 80 gallons.
No question, YETI is a leader in the rotomolded cooler market, however, since we are attempting to review the best rotomolded coolers for the money, we thought it would be prudent to take a look at the other coolers comparable to Yeti and see if any of them should be in the running.
Now, let’s take a look at several other “YETI like” coolers to see how they stack up and which one is truly the best rotomolded cooler for the money. After reading several reviews, we decided to look at ORCA, ORION, RTIC, PELICAN, and GRIZZLY brands compared to YETI to determine:
We really had difficulty narrowing the margin between these cooler brands. In the final analysis we chose Pelican Coolers as our #1 Best Cooler for the money for their length in the industry, their customer service, and their superior latching system.
PELICAN vs YETI
- PELICAN is manufactured in USA*
- PELICAN is an industry leader since the 1970’s
- PELICAN performed very well in ice retention
- PELICAN offers a Lifetime Warranty vs. YETI’S 5 years
- PELICAN had the overall best user reviews of the coolers we reviewed with fewer negative reviews
- PELICAN’S latch system is highly rated among users
- PELICAN is Certified Bear Resistant by IGBC**
Pelican was founded in 1976 in California by Dave and Arline Parker. Since that time the company has grown and has become known as an industry leader,
“in the design and manufacture of high performance protective cases, temperature controlled packaging solutions, advanced portable lighting systems and rugged gear for professionals and outdoor enthusiasts alike.”
We have a soft spot for ORCA coolers as it is manufactured not only in the USA, but in our home state of Tennessee. As previously mentioned, it was a close run between Pelican coolers and ORCA brand coolers.
ORCA vs YETI
- ORCA is manufactured in USA
- ORCA equalled and sometimes exceeded ice retention over a YETI
- ORCA offers a Lifetime Warranty vs. YETI’S 5 years
- ORCA offers 8 color selections vs YETI’S 3 colors**
Our only reasons for giving ORCA the second position were that they are newer on the market and the Pelican latching system really outweighed in the reviews between the two cooler brands. However, if you are into personalizing your cooler with a college team and want a cooler comparable to YETI, but slightly less expensive you may wish to consider an ORCA cooler.
**YETI does offer more Collegiate options than ORCA so if this is a consideration in your purchase, YETI may be a better option
However, we placed them at the bottom of the list because Orion is really no less expensive than Yeti and doesn’t offer a great deal of benefit over Yeti, unless you desire the cool colors or being Made in the USA is a deal breaker. However, if that is the case, we point you back to ORCA for a little less expense.
Grizzly fell to the bottom primarily for complaints about weight.
We chose the Pelican Ultra 70QT as the Best Cooler for Camping among all the previously mentioned coolers, again, for its superior build and it’s durability against attack by two Grizzly’s.
*Disclaimer: While these coolers are tested and verified by the IGBC as being Grizzly Bear resistant, they do require additional bolts or pad-locks to be truly resistant. You can read more about their testing process and product recommendations here.
One thing that can be said about all of these rotomolded coolers; they can be heavy! If you anticipate using your rotomolded cooler for the beach or know you will need to move it around a lot, you may want to consider a cooler with wheels.
Pelican was the only brand we found in our research that had a cooler with wheels already installed. A few other brands offer caddies for an additional cost, but for already stated reasons, we chose Pelican.
There are three sizes available in the Pelican Wheeled Coolers
RTIC Coolers are our choice for the cheapest rotomolded cooler that is still comparable to YETI. In fact, these coolers have had a bit of controversy with YETI in the past, but we understand an amicable agreement was reached between the two companies.
RTIC vs YETI
- RTIC is less expensive than ORCA, YETI, and Pelican with comparable quality design and features
- Receives high ratings by former YETI owners
- Ice retention as high as 7 days
- Not manufactured in the USA*
Despite these legal issues and changes made to RTIC coolers, they remain a viable alternative to YETI for those seeking a more affordable cooler without sacrificing the superior ice retention, durability, and quality found in the high end cooler market.
*RTIC came in last primarily because it is manufactured outside of the USA and there are fewer color and collegiate options. Beyond that, it is an equivalent option to YETI so if money is an issue, RTIC may be a good choice for you.
Enjoy hiking with your family? Check out our 9 Best Tips for hiking with kids by Outdoor Travel bloggers.
Need ideas for gifts for the outdoor enthusiasts in your life? Check our Gifts for Hikers Guide
If you are like me and have a wide food and have trouble finding a good hiking shoe, check out our Best Shoes for a Wide Toe Box.